February 05, 2022

 

ESG: Wider Consequences of Management Behaviour

 

The tone at the top dictates the Company's culture, and the Company's culture has a wide-ranging impact on its performance, valuations, and long-term sustainability. While the aggressive approach and risk-taking attitude of promoters and CEOs are often the cause for the bullish growth of a company, the same aggression can manifest in different ways and be the cause of the Company's demise. Investors are particularly wary of management behaviour and demand that they uphold themselves to the highest standards for prudent behaviour. Recently, the Chairman of Credit-Suisse was asked to step down after a board investigation showed that he breached the COVID quarantine rules watching the Wimbledon and European Championship finals and also used the office jet for personal trips.

Further, Company policies and CEO employment agreements typically contain provisions for termination of employment due to improper behaviour. In turn, a trigger of such provision could have consequences under other arrangements such as shareholder agreements. Thus, while senior management behaviour creates larger issues for the Company's overall health, the removal of senior management pursuant to such behaviour can also have consequences for the shareholders and individuals involved. Thus, the Board of Directors tread carefully in such circumstances and undertake detailed investigations before deciding.

In India, we now see the "voluntary leave" announced by the Managing Director and Co-founder of Bharat Pe and his wife, as the Board conducts an internal investigation pursuant to the alleged incident of inappropriate behaviour towards a certain bank employee.

The Emerging controversy

Ashneer Grover is the co-founder and Managing Director of Bharat Pe. Bharat Pe is recognised as one of the biggest fintech companies in India after it raised an amount of $370 million from its investors, with Ashneer Grover being at the helm of it all.1 It boasts of equity funding from top equity funds, including Sequoia, Coatue Management, Insight Partners, Dragoneer Investment Group, Steadfast Capital and Tiger Global.[AK1]

In October 2021, Ashneer Grover and his wife, Madhuri Grover, had sent a legal notice to Kotak Mahindra Bank ("Kotak") for its failure to provide them funding for the Initial Public Offering ("IPO") of Nykaa2, a fashion and cosmetic e-commerce startup in India and to allocate its shares in the HNI/NII category.3  The notice alleges that after having been given repeated assurances that Kotak would ensure the allotment of shares in the IPO to the Grovers, Kotak later communicated its inability to provide IPO financing for the Nykaa IPO.4 Kotak reportedly replied to the said notice and also objected to inappropriate language used by Mr. Grover. [AK2]

While the existence of such a dispute was itself not an issue, a leaked audio clip brought this particular dispute to the front page of every major newspaper! At the beginning of January 2022, an anonymous Twitter handle had posted an audio clip that showcased three persons in a heated conversation, a couple and a bank employee. It showcased the male's abusive tone and scurrilous approach towards the bank employee. This was alleged to be the voices of Ashneer Grover, his wife and an employee of Kotak Mahindra Bank.5

While this audio clip was of a dispute between Grovers and Kotak, it brought the behaviour of the senior management to the fore.6 The discussion quickly escalated into the managing director's behaviour in the Company and the 'toxic' work culture. On January 19, 2022, the Board of Directors of Bharat Pe approved the voluntary leave of Mr. Grover till the end of March 2022. They stated that the move is "in the best interests of the company, our employees and investors, and the millions of merchants we support each day."7 Currently, an internal investigation is underway.

Potential Consequences

Such issues can have consequences which are bigger than what a short voluntary leave by the Managing Director of the Company can solve. It was not very long ago that Rahul Yadav, the CEO of Housing.com, an Indian startup, was fired by the Board of Directors pursuant to similar controversies, which had connections with his "often-abrasive communication with investors and media" and his conduct within the Company as well.8 Similarly, Michael Lofthouse, the CEO and Founder of Soli8, a cloud computing agency in the USA was filmed making racial comments during an occasion, pursuant to which, he was seen leaving the Company after a huge upheaval.9 A similar issue had arisen in 2017 in context of Uber, where its founder-director infamously stepped down due to the issues with prevailing corporate culture.

A removal of Bharat Pe's Founder could have wider implications for the Founder himself and the investors. As per the Articles of Association of Bharat Pe, if the Founder's employment is terminated due to a material breach of the employment agreement or for any gross negligence or wilful misconduct as determined by a Big4Firm, a large chunk of the shares held by such Founder can be bought out at the lower of the fair market value or the price paid by the Founder for such shares. Thus, understandably all parties are immediately lawyering up as if pursuant to the internal investigation, an appropriate cause is identified for termination of the Founder's employment, it can have a significant monetary consequence for all players involved.

India Inc. is at an age where the norms and recognition of ESG metrics is on the rise. Investors and shareholders are seen taking a front seat to ensure that their rights are acknowledged and enforced.10 The approach taken by the Board of Bharat Pe showcases how matters, which are not necessarily within the four corners of a company's business, can, very quickly, escalate and have a direct impact on a company and all its stakeholders.


Ashish Kabra & Sahil Kanuga

(We acknowledge and thank Rithika Mathur, Student National Law University Odisha, Cuttack for her assistance on this hotline.)

You can direct your queries or comments to the authors


1 'BharatPe redefined India's payment ecosystem. The unicorn now wants to challenge India's banks', Forbes India, (Sep 9, 2022), https://www.forbesindia.com/article/take-one-big-story-of-the-day/bharatpe-redefined-indias-payment-ecosystem-the-unicorn-now-wants-to-challenge-indias-banks/70299/1

2 FSN E-Commerce Ventures Ltd.

3 'Ashneer Grover Case: Kotak Mahindra Bank pursuing appropriate legal action', Business Standard (Jan 10, 2022), https://www.business-standard.com/article/finance/ashneer-grover-case-kotak-mahindra-bank-pursuing-appropriate-legal-action-122011000050_1.html

4 'Tussle between Kotak Bank and BharatPe's Ashneer Grover Takes Ugly Turn; Raises Larger Questions', Money Life (Jan 10, 2022) https://www.moneylife.in/article/tussle-between-kotak-bank-and-bharatpes-ashneer-grover-takes-ugly-turn-raises-larger-questions/66078.html.  

5 'The new rage in startup town', Economic Times (Jan 19, 2022), https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/tech/startups/the-new-rage-in-startup-town/articleshow/88917006.cms

6 https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/tech/startups/the-new-rage-in-startup-town/articleshow/88917006.cms

7 'BharatPe's Ashneer Grover takes voluntary leave till March-end', Hindustan Times, (Jan 19, 2022) https://www.hindustantimes.com/business/bharatpes-ashneer-grover-takes-voluntary-leave-till-marchend-101642612598329-amp.html

8 'Housing.com fires CEO Rahul Yadav', Money Life (July 1, 2015) https://www.moneylife.in/article/housingcom-fires-ceo-rahul-yadav/42554.html.

9 'When startup founders lose the plot', Economic Times (Jan 15, 2022), https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/tech/newsletters/ettech-unwrapped/when-founders-lose-the-plot/articleshow/88905830.cms?from=mdr.

10 'Explainer: How Invesco and Indian TV giant Zee got caught in legal row', Reuters (Oct 13, 2022), https://www.reuters.com/world/india/how-invesco-indian-tv-giant-zee-got-caught-legal-row-2021-10-13/


Disclaimer

The contents of this hotline should not be construed as legal opinion. View detailed disclaimer.

This Hotline provides general information existing at the time of preparation. The Hotline is intended as a news update and Nishith Desai Associates neither assumes nor accepts any responsibility for any loss arising to any person acting or refraining from acting as a result of any material contained in this Hotline. It is recommended that professional advice be taken based on the specific facts and circumstances. This Hotline does not substitute the need to refer to the original pronouncements.

This is not a Spam mail. You have received this mail because you have either requested for it or someone must have suggested your name. Since India has no anti-spamming law, we refer to the US directive, which states that a mail cannot be considered Spam if it contains the sender's contact information, which this mail does. In case this mail doesn't concern you, please unsubscribe from mailing list.


February 05, 2022

ESG: Wider Consequences of Management Behaviour

 

The tone at the top dictates the Company's culture, and the Company's culture has a wide-ranging impact on its performance, valuations, and long-term sustainability. While the aggressive approach and risk-taking attitude of promoters and CEOs are often the cause for the bullish growth of a company, the same aggression can manifest in different ways and be the cause of the Company's demise. Investors are particularly wary of management behaviour and demand that they uphold themselves to the highest standards for prudent behaviour. Recently, the Chairman of Credit-Suisse was asked to step down after a board investigation showed that he breached the COVID quarantine rules watching the Wimbledon and European Championship finals and also used the office jet for personal trips.

Further, Company policies and CEO employment agreements typically contain provisions for termination of employment due to improper behaviour. In turn, a trigger of such provision could have consequences under other arrangements such as shareholder agreements. Thus, while senior management behaviour creates larger issues for the Company's overall health, the removal of senior management pursuant to such behaviour can also have consequences for the shareholders and individuals involved. Thus, the Board of Directors tread carefully in such circumstances and undertake detailed investigations before deciding.

In India, we now see the "voluntary leave" announced by the Managing Director and Co-founder of Bharat Pe and his wife, as the Board conducts an internal investigation pursuant to the alleged incident of inappropriate behaviour towards a certain bank employee.

The Emerging controversy

Ashneer Grover is the co-founder and Managing Director of Bharat Pe. Bharat Pe is recognised as one of the biggest fintech companies in India after it raised an amount of $370 million from its investors, with Ashneer Grover being at the helm of it all.1 It boasts of equity funding from top equity funds, including Sequoia, Coatue Management, Insight Partners, Dragoneer Investment Group, Steadfast Capital and Tiger Global.[AK1]

In October 2021, Ashneer Grover and his wife, Madhuri Grover, had sent a legal notice to Kotak Mahindra Bank ("Kotak") for its failure to provide them funding for the Initial Public Offering ("IPO") of Nykaa2, a fashion and cosmetic e-commerce startup in India and to allocate its shares in the HNI/NII category.3  The notice alleges that after having been given repeated assurances that Kotak would ensure the allotment of shares in the IPO to the Grovers, Kotak later communicated its inability to provide IPO financing for the Nykaa IPO.4 Kotak reportedly replied to the said notice and also objected to inappropriate language used by Mr. Grover. [AK2]

While the existence of such a dispute was itself not an issue, a leaked audio clip brought this particular dispute to the front page of every major newspaper! At the beginning of January 2022, an anonymous Twitter handle had posted an audio clip that showcased three persons in a heated conversation, a couple and a bank employee. It showcased the male's abusive tone and scurrilous approach towards the bank employee. This was alleged to be the voices of Ashneer Grover, his wife and an employee of Kotak Mahindra Bank.5

While this audio clip was of a dispute between Grovers and Kotak, it brought the behaviour of the senior management to the fore.6 The discussion quickly escalated into the managing director's behaviour in the Company and the 'toxic' work culture. On January 19, 2022, the Board of Directors of Bharat Pe approved the voluntary leave of Mr. Grover till the end of March 2022. They stated that the move is "in the best interests of the company, our employees and investors, and the millions of merchants we support each day."7 Currently, an internal investigation is underway.

Potential Consequences

Such issues can have consequences which are bigger than what a short voluntary leave by the Managing Director of the Company can solve. It was not very long ago that Rahul Yadav, the CEO of Housing.com, an Indian startup, was fired by the Board of Directors pursuant to similar controversies, which had connections with his "often-abrasive communication with investors and media" and his conduct within the Company as well.8 Similarly, Michael Lofthouse, the CEO and Founder of Soli8, a cloud computing agency in the USA was filmed making racial comments during an occasion, pursuant to which, he was seen leaving the Company after a huge upheaval.9 A similar issue had arisen in 2017 in context of Uber, where its founder-director infamously stepped down due to the issues with prevailing corporate culture.

A removal of Bharat Pe's Founder could have wider implications for the Founder himself and the investors. As per the Articles of Association of Bharat Pe, if the Founder's employment is terminated due to a material breach of the employment agreement or for any gross negligence or wilful misconduct as determined by a Big4Firm, a large chunk of the shares held by such Founder can be bought out at the lower of the fair market value or the price paid by the Founder for such shares. Thus, understandably all parties are immediately lawyering up as if pursuant to the internal investigation, an appropriate cause is identified for termination of the Founder's employment, it can have a significant monetary consequence for all players involved.

India Inc. is at an age where the norms and recognition of ESG metrics is on the rise. Investors and shareholders are seen taking a front seat to ensure that their rights are acknowledged and enforced.10 The approach taken by the Board of Bharat Pe showcases how matters, which are not necessarily within the four corners of a company's business, can, very quickly, escalate and have a direct impact on a company and all its stakeholders.

 


Ashish Kabra & Sahil Kanuga

(We acknowledge and thank Rithika Mathur, Student National Law University Odisha, Cuttack for her assistance on this hotline.)

You can direct your queries or comments to the authors


1 'BharatPe redefined India's payment ecosystem. The unicorn now wants to challenge India's banks', Forbes India, (Sep 9, 2022), https://www.forbesindia.com/article/take-one-big-story-of-the-day/bharatpe-redefined-indias-payment-ecosystem-the-unicorn-now-wants-to-challenge-indias-banks/70299/1

2 FSN E-Commerce Ventures Ltd.

3 'Ashneer Grover Case: Kotak Mahindra Bank pursuing appropriate legal action', Business Standard (Jan 10, 2022), https://www.business-standard.com/article/finance/ashneer-grover-case-kotak-mahindra-bank-pursuing-appropriate-legal-action-122011000050_1.html

4 'Tussle between Kotak Bank and BharatPe's Ashneer Grover Takes Ugly Turn; Raises Larger Questions', Money Life (Jan 10, 2022) https://www.moneylife.in/article/tussle-between-kotak-bank-and-bharatpes-ashneer-grover-takes-ugly-turn-raises-larger-questions/66078.html.  

5 'The new rage in startup town', Economic Times (Jan 19, 2022), https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/tech/startups/the-new-rage-in-startup-town/articleshow/88917006.cms

6 https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/tech/startups/the-new-rage-in-startup-town/articleshow/88917006.cms

7 'BharatPe's Ashneer Grover takes voluntary leave till March-end', Hindustan Times, (Jan 19, 2022) https://www.hindustantimes.com/business/bharatpes-ashneer-grover-takes-voluntary-leave-till-marchend-101642612598329-amp.html

8 'Housing.com fires CEO Rahul Yadav', Money Life (July 1, 2015) https://www.moneylife.in/article/housingcom-fires-ceo-rahul-yadav/42554.html.

9 'When startup founders lose the plot', Economic Times (Jan 15, 2022), https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/tech/newsletters/ettech-unwrapped/when-founders-lose-the-plot/articleshow/88905830.cms?from=mdr.

10 'Explainer: How Invesco and Indian TV giant Zee got caught in legal row', Reuters (Oct 13, 2022), https://www.reuters.com/world/india/how-invesco-indian-tv-giant-zee-got-caught-legal-row-2021-10-13/


Disclaimer

The contents of this hotline should not be construed as legal opinion. View detailed disclaimer.

This Hotline provides general information existing at the time of preparation. The Hotline is intended as a news update and Nishith Desai Associates neither assumes nor accepts any responsibility for any loss arising to any person acting or refraining from acting as a result of any material contained in this Hotline. It is recommended that professional advice be taken based on the specific facts and circumstances. This Hotline does not substitute the need to refer to the original pronouncements.

This is not a Spam mail. You have received this mail because you have either requested for it or someone must have suggested your name. Since India has no anti-spamming law, we refer to the US directive, which states that a mail cannot be considered Spam if it contains the sender's contact information, which this mail does. In case this mail doesn't concern you, please unsubscribe from mailing list.

 
 

 

Want to work with us?

We aspire to build the next generation of socially-conscious lawyers who strive to make the world a better place.

At NDA, there is always room for the right people! A platform for self-driven intrapreneurs solving complex problems through research, academics, thought leadership and innovation, we are a community of non-hierarchical, non-siloed professionals doing extraordinary work for the world’s best clients.

We welcome the industry’s best talent - inspired, competent, proactive and research minded- with credentials in Corporate Law (in particular M&A/PE Fund Formation), International Tax , TMT and cross-border dispute resolution.

Write to happiness@nishithdesai.com

To learn more about us Click here.

 

NDA Connect

Connect with us at events, 
conferences and seminars.

 
 

Mobile App

 

Click here for

Apple IOS

Android

   
 

Proud Moments

Chambers and Partners Asia-Pacific: Band 1 for Employment, Lifesciences, Tax and TMT, 2022

AsiaLaw Asia-Pacific Guide 2022: Ranked ‘Outstanding’ for Media & Entertainment, Technology & Communications, Labor & Employment, Regulatory, Private Equity, Tax

Who's Who Legal: Thought Leaders India 2022: Nishith M Desai (Corporate Tax - Advisory, Corporate Tax - Controversy and Private Funds – Formation), Vikram Shroff (Labour & Employment and Pensions & Benefits) and Vyapak Desai (Arbitration)

Benchmark Litigation Asia-Pacific: Tier 1 for Tax, Labour and Employment, International Arbitration, Government and Regulatory, 2021

Legal500 Asia-Pacific: Tier 1 for Tax, Data Protection, Labour and Employment, Private Equity and Investment Funds, 2021

IFLR1000: Tier 1 for Private Equity and Tier 2 for Project Development: Telecommunications Networks, 2021

FT Innovative Lawyers Asia Pacific 2019 Awards: NDA ranked 2nd in the Most Innovative Law Firm category (Asia-Pacific Headquartered)

RSG-Financial Times: India’s Most Innovative Law Firm 2019, 2017, 2016, 2015, 2014